Tag Archives: Children’s Rights


UN Committee Urges Iran to Comply with their International Obligations


IRI Delgation CRC Review  Jan 2015
by
Insight Iran
12:06 PM GMT
February 5th, 2016
Download PDF

UN Committee Urges Iran to Comply with their International Obligations

Following a review of the situation of children in Iran, the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC) has published its concluding observations on the combined third and fourth periodic reports of the Islamic Republic of Iran (IRI). The report criticises the IRI in quite a few number of areas where national laws and practices fail to comply with international standards in relation to children’s rights. See the full report here.

Definition of the child, for instance, has been a major area of concern for the civil society and the Committee has taken a strong position on this matter. In a detailed report of February 2015, Insight Iran had submitted to the Committee that the age of puberty under Islamic Shari’a is still the definitive criterion for criminal responsibility and varies for boys and girls. It allows girls as young as 8 years and 9 months of age and boys of 14 years and 7 months to be held criminally responsible. This clearly is a very “low” and “discriminatory” standard, particularly against girls.

The Committee has raised serious concerns that despite its previous recommendations, the age of majority in Iran remains set at pre-defined ages of puberty for girls at 9 and for boys at 15 lunar years which results in depriving girls and boys above these ages from the protection under the Convention.

The Committee has also expressed grave concern about the persisting discrimination against girls in the IRI’s legislation and in practice in many aspects of life, including the discriminatory treatment of girls in family relations, criminal justice system, and compensation for physical injury, among others. Insight Iran had raised the issue of discrimination between boys and girls in various areas including compensation for bodily injuries.

Similarly, the Committee is deeply concerned about the law age of marriage in Iran (13 years for girls and 15 years for boys) and emphasised that it gravely violates rights under the Convention and places children, in particular girls at risk of forced and early marriages with irreversible consequences on their physical and mental health and development.

The Committee has urged the IRI to revise as a matter of urgency and priority its legislation to ensure that all persons below the age of 18 years, without exceptions, are considered as children and provided with all rights under the Convention. The Committee also urges the IRI to further increase the minimum age for marriage for both girls and boys to 18 years, and to take all necessary measures to eliminate child marriages in line with the IRI’s obligations under the Convention.

Insight Iran had submitted to the Committee that article 301 combined with article 612 of the Islamic Penal Code (2013), provides for lighter punishment if a murder is committed by a father or a paternal grandfather of the victim, more often in the name of so called “honour”. In such cases, judges have a full discretion and can even decide to release the perpetrator without any punishment paving a way for total impunity for killing one’s child.

The Committee has strongly urged the IRI to repeal article 301 of the Islamic Penal Code, and ensure that all perpetrators of murders committed in the name of so-called “honour” receive penalties commensurate with the gravity of their crimes.

Under article 91 of the Islamic Penal Code of 2013, in special conditions, children below the age of 18 years who have been sentenced to hudud and qisas punishments could be granted retrial and exemption from hudud and qisas punishments. However, Insight Iran had raised concern that such exemptions are under full discretion of judges who are allowed, but not obliged to seek forensic expert opinion.

The Committee has expressed serious concern about this issue and that several persons have been re-sentenced to death following such re-trials. The Committee deplores that the IRI continues to execute children and those who have committed a crime while under 18 years of age, despite its previous recommendations and numerous criticisms by human rights treaty bodies.

The Committee has strongly urged the IRI as a matter of utmost priority to:

  • End the execution of children and persons who committed a crime under the age of 18;
  • Take legislative measures to abolish the death sentence for the crimes of hudud and qisas for persons who committed a crime under the age of 18 years in the Islamic Penal Code without leaving any discretion to the courts; and
  • Commute all existing sentences for offenders on death row who committed a crime under the age of 18 years.

 

Insight Iran had urged the Committee to consider the differences between ta’zir crimes on the one hand and hudud and qisas on the other hand. We had submitted that while corporal punishment and flogging of children for the ta’zir category has been abolished for children under the new IPC, the same has not taken place with regard to Hudud and Qisas.

The Committee has paid a careful attention to these differences and while welcoming the changes in the 2013 Islamic Penal Code, it “remains seriously concerned that the IPC retains the punishment of children who reached the legal age of criminal responsibility (9 lunar years for girls and 15 years for boys) for crimes under the categories of Hudud and Qisas with sentences involving torture or cruel, degrading treatment or punishment, which has been and continue to be applied to children.”

 

Insight Iran had submitted an alternative report to the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child in advance of the Committee’s review of the IRI’s Periodic Report. The submission examined the IRI’s criminal justice system when dealing with crimes committed by, and against, children. The executive summary of the Insight Iran’s submission can be downloaded here.

Insight Iran had also joined other leading human rights NGOs such as Amnesty International, Justice for Iran, Iran Human Rights, and Baha’i International Community and made a joint submission to the Committee. One of the most comprehensive of its kind, the joint submission covered various areas of concern with regard to the IRI’s commitments pursuant to the CRC. We also took part in the Committee’s pre-sessional meeting in June 2015 in Geneva, where the submissions were considered and prepared for the main session of the review of the IRI January this year. All the submissions can be found here.

Joint Public Statement: It is Time to Put Children First


Logos

 

In April 2015, Insight Iran, as a part of a coalition of 11 human rights NGOs, made a joint submission to the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child and made substantial recommendations. One of the most comprehensive of its kind, our joint submission covered various areas of concern with regard to the IRI’s commitments pursuant to the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Read the executive summary of the Insight Iran’s submission here.

In June 2015, during the Pre-Session of the Committee on Iran, our coalition was given the opportunity to discuss their concerns directly with the Committee experts and shed light on complex issues that required further explanation. Later on, on 22 June 2015, the Committee published the List of Issues in relation to the fourth periodic report of the Islamic Republic of Iran.

Insight Iran welcomes the Committee’s detailed and methodical approach and their willingness to address key issues and challenges despite all the restraints on the time and resources of the Committee. We are also delighted to see that our submission have contributed to the work of the Committee.

In a joint public statement published today, our coalition reflected on the List of Issues and formal request of the Committee to Iran to respond to over 30 concerns ahead of the main session of the Committee in Geneva in January 2016, where, Iran’s children’s rights record will be scrutinised.

 

JOINT PUBLIC STATEMENT

20 July 2015

Iran: 20 years of unfulfilled promises: It is time to put children first

Two decades on from Iran’s ratification of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC), the Iranian authorities continue to show a shocking lack of respect for the basic human rights of children, 10 human rights groups said today on the 21st anniversary of the ratification of the treaty. The joint statement follows the publication of a formal request by the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (Committee) for Iran to respond to over 30 concerns ahead of a meeting in Geneva in January 2016 that will scrutinize Iran’s children’s rights record.

The Committee’s list of concerns reflects a disturbing trail of broken promises since Iran’s ratification of the CRC in July 1994, a state of affairs that has been the subject of comment and condemnation by human rights groups over the past 20 years.

Girls as young as nine and boys as young as 15 continue to be treated and sentenced in the same way as adults for most offences. Death sentences are still imposed and carried out for crimes allegedly committed by persons below 18 years of age. The legal age of marriage remains 13 for girls and 15 for boys with official statistics confirming thousands of marriages of children below 15 years. Children belonging to ethnic minorities are denied the opportunity to learn and use their mother language and to engage in their cultural practices, essential for the development of their cultural identity. Similarly, children belonging to religious minorities experience pervasive abuse and discrimination because of their or their parents’ religious beliefs. Discrimination and violence, including domestic violence and police brutality, also remains a reality for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender children.

Successive Iranian governments and parliaments have failed to undertake the root-and-branch reforms that are sorely needed to address these concerns. At best, they have refused to acknowledge the scale of such concerns and announced token initiatives, which have rarely been translated into a cohesive and sustained strategy. At worst, they have relied on a general and vaguely worded reservation about compliance with Islamic law to negate the whole object and purpose of the CRC with respect to key issues such as juvenile executions, child marriage and discrimination.

After two decades, such token gestures and unfulfilled promises are simply unacceptable. There must be no “ifs”, no “buts” about ending violence and discrimination against children.

The fourth periodic review of Iran by the Committee is an opportune moment for the Iranian authorities to break with their persistent policy of denial and empty rhetoric and begin delivering long-delayed reforms to ensure the human rights of children, without discrimination, in all matters including at school, in the family, in courts, before administrative bodies and in society in general.

 

KEY CONCERNS OF THE UN COMMITTEE ON THE RIGHTS OF THE CHILD

Age of majority and adult criminal responsibility

As a state party to the CRC, Iran has pledged to ensure that all legislation defines a child as a person under the age of 18 years and the age of criminal responsibility, conforms to the CRC both in law and practice.[1] However, the age of adult criminal responsibility remains nine lunar years for girls and 15 lunar years for boys. Above this age, in cases of hodud (offences against God carrying inalterable punishments prescribed by Shari’a law) and qesas (retribution-in-kind connected with a criminal act), a child is generally convicted and sentenced in the same way as adults, unless a judge determines that he or she did not comprehend the nature of the crime or its consequences or his or her mental growth and maturity are in doubt. The Committee has asked Iran to indicate any measures taken to ensure the age of criminal responsibility conforms to the CRC, both in law and practice.

 

Juvenile executions

Iran continues to impose and carry out death sentences for crimes allegedly committed by persons below 18 years of age, despite an absolute prohibition on such executions under international law, including the CRC. At least 72 juvenile offenders are believed to have been executed between 2005 and 2014 and at least 160 juvenile offenders are believed to remain on death row.

The Committee has asked Iran to provide information on the outcome and progress of the judicial review of cases of persons on death row for crimes committed when they were below the age of 18 years based on a 2014 “pilot judgment” by Iran’s Supreme Court. It has also asked for detailed information on the number of persons awaiting execution for crimes allegedly committed when they were below the age of 18 years and on the fate of Saman Naseem and Barzan Nasrollahzadeh, two juvenile offenders who were reported to be awaiting execution earlier this year.

 

Minimum age of marriage

The legal age of marriage continues to be 13 for girls and 15 for boys. However, girls below 13 and boys below 15 can be married with the consent of their guardian and the approval of a court. The Committee has asked the Iranian government to “provide information on the measures taken to eliminate the harmful practice of child marriage, including forced marriage” and “comment on the information received according to which thousands of marriages of children below 13 years take place every year and that many girls commit suicide to escape such marriages.”

In light of Iran’s obligation to protect children from sexual abuse and exploitation, the Committee has further asked if “Iran intends to repeal article 1108 of its Civil Code, which obliges wives, including married girls, to sexual submission and obedience towards their husbands.” Denial of access to free and compulsory education to girls if pregnant or if their husbands so wish are among the concerns the Committee has raised in relation to the harmful practice of child marriage.

 

Children belonging to religious minorities

Lack of respect for freedom of religion and belief is another concern identified in the Committee’s list of issues. Iran has been asked to identify efforts undertaken to protect children

belonging to religious minorities, in particular Baha’i, Sufi and Yarsan children, as well as children from atheist and agnostic families. The Committee has noted with concern the arrest and detention of Baha’i teachers and an announcement by the Advocacy Council for the Right to Education in 2012 that many Iranian students had been banned from education for their religious beliefs. It has asked Iran to inform the Committee about the measures taken to ensure that all children, in particular children belonging to religious minorities, benefit from free and compulsory education, without any restrictions.

 

Children belonging to ethnic minorities

Widespread discrimination against children from ethnic minorities such as the Ahwazi Arab, Azerbaijani Turk, Baloch and Kurdish minorities continue in everyday life, including in access to education, and is another concern featured in the Committee’s list of issues. Iran has been asked to provide information on the measures taken to provide ethnic minorities with an opportunity to study in their native languages. It has also been asked to indicate the measures taken to address reported targeted arrests, detentions, imprisonments, killings, torture and executions against such groups by the law-enforcing and judicial authorities.

 

Torture and other ill-treatment

The Committee’s list of issues raises concerns that children can be subjected to flogging, stoning and amputation for a range of offences including, for girls, not wearing a hijab.

The Committee has asked Iran to provide detailed information on all cases of children subjected to these cruel and inhumane practices, which violate the absolute prohibition on torture under international law.

 

Abuse and violence

Abuses faced by children in Iran range from domestic violence, including sexual abuse and honour killings, at home to violent forms of discipline at school; from female genital mutilation, especially in the provinces of Kurdistan, Western Azerbaijan, Kermanshahh, Illam, Lorestan and Hormozghan, to police brutality against refugee and migrant children and children living and working on the streets. The Committee has further requested that Iran provide statistical data for the past three years on such cases of abuse and violence against children, and on prosecutions and penalties to perpetrators, and redress and compensation offered to the victims.

The Committee has highlighted in this regard the necessity of identifying how the vulnerability of children to such abuses depends on other aspects of their identity, such as gender, ethnic origin, religion, sexual orientation or gender identity, disability, socio-economic background, and immigration status, and asked Iran to indicate the measures taken to provide special protection to the children who are the most likely to be subjected to such abuse and violence, including gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender children.

 

BACKGROUND

The CRC is the most widely ratified international human rights treaty and establishes global standards to ensure the protection, survival, and development of all children, without discrimination. The Committee on the Rights of the Child reviews the record of countries that ratify the CRC every five years. As part of this process, the state party submits a state report to the Committee. The Committee also receives information from non-governmental organizations and UN sources to identify areas of progress and concern and to recommend steps that the country should take to improve the lives of children.

In March 2015, the 10 human rights groups submitted a joint report to the Committee, which is available on the website of Amnesty International at the following link: https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/mde13/2118/2015/en/

In June 2015, the Committee held a pre-session with non-governmental organizations, including the 10 human rights groups issuing this joint statement, and subsequently adopted a list of issues for Iran, which will form the basis for the review scheduled for the 71st Session of the Committee in January 2016: http://tbinternet.ohchr.org/Treaties/CRC/Shared%20Documents/IRN/CRC_C_IRN_Q_3- 4_20953_E.pdf

The Iranian government has been asked to respond to the concerns raised in the list of issues, if possible before 15 October 2015.

*****************************************************

[1] The CRC has determined the age of 18 as the standard age of entering into majority and full criminal responsibility, without any discrimination between boys and girls. This is a different matter from the minimum age of criminal responsibility, the age below which children shall not be arrested and charged with a crime. The minimum age of criminal responsibility varies around the world but the CRC has said in its General Comment 10, para 32: “A minimum age of criminal responsibility below the age of 12 years is considered by the Committee not to be internationally acceptable. States parties are encouraged to increase their lower minimum age of criminal responsibility to the age of 12 years as the absolute minimum age and to continue to increase it to a higher age level.”

 

For more information or to arrange interviews, please contact: